Closing the COVID-19 trust deficit


The arrival of COVID-19 vaccines is giving the world hope of ending the pandemic, but many countries remain consumed by the virus's spread. So, as we wait for widespread availability and distribution of the vaccines, preventive health measures such as social distancing, mask-wearing and hand-washing will remain critical to containing the disease.

For some, following this guidance is not feasible. Many poor people, for example, must contend with overcrowding, limited access to clean water and soap, and the absence of robust social safety nets.

Beyond material constraints, however, lie others related to information and trust. Some may be unaware of public-health guidelines or may not understand the specific steps to follow. Misinformation about COVID-19 can undermine the recommended measures. And in some contexts, lack of confidence in the health system itself may reduce adherence to guidelines.

While biomedical researchers and public-health experts scrambled to learn about the novel coronavirus in early 2020, economists and other social scientists set to work testing COVID-19 policies and programs. The body of evidence they have developed holds important lessons for overcoming information constraints, combating misinformation, and building trust in health systems. These insights may also help to improve delivery and increase uptake of COVID-19 vaccines.

One study involved sending two-and-a-half-minute videos about COVID-19 via text message to 25 million people in West Bengal, India. The videos instructed them to report any symptoms to community health workers and emphasized the importance of adopting preventive behaviors. Recipients subsequently reported traveling less and washing their hands more often, and doubled their reporting of symptoms to health workers.

This striking result may appear surprising, given that policymakers had been sending COVID-19 prevention messages for weeks to the people who received the videos. One possible reason why the video messages proved more effective is that they provided specific, actionable information about which symptoms to look out for, and specified the steps people should take to report them and prevent disease.

Even when information is specific and actionable, outcomes may vary. One ongoing study in Uganda, for example, seeks to understand the relative effects of emphasizing individual versus societal benefits on people's adherence to COVID-19 public-health guidelines.

And what about the messenger? In the Indian study, the person providing information in the video – the Nobel laureate economist Abhijit Banerjee – was well known, and his message may thus have had an outsize impact. But that study also showed the role peers can play. Even those who did not receive the public-health messages reported increased adherence to COVID-19 guidelines as they observed and emulated their neighbors' changed behavior.

That raises the question of whether peers are more effective than a third party in influencing behavior. In Zambia, researchers are asking individuals to communicate COVID-19 health information to their family and friends via SMS, and comparing the impact on preventive behavior to the impact of messages from a central authority.

Policymakers may also need to go beyond simply communicating prevention guidelines and more proactively combat misinformation that leads to confusion and mistrust. In Zimbabwe, local organizations sent WhatsApp messages to their newsletter subscribers to convey truthful information about COVID-19 and debunk misinformation about fake cures. These messages from a trusted source increased knowledge about the disease and reduced reported harmful behavior such as violating lockdown orders.

Similarly, economists in Mexico are working with its public health institute to assess how a messenger's political leanings and credibility influence the level of trust in the message and adherence to guidelines.

The question of trust is not limited to concerns about misinformation. We learned from the 2014-16 Ebola crisis in West Africa that policies that increase confidence in the health system can improve cooperation with health guidelines, in turn leading to increased testing and reduced disease spread and mortality.

The factors helping to overcome lack of trust in a health system can vary greatly depending on the context. In the US, where health inequities across racial groups are large, a study of preventive care found that black men were more likely to trust black physicians and more likely to take up various preventive health measures, including the flu vaccine, if they consulted one.

These results were supported by a separate study in the US, which found that black adults who watched a physician-delivered video on COVID-19 prevention were more likely to seek out additional information if the physician in the video was also black.

As we enter further uncharted territory with COVID-19 vaccines, this research on how to boost adoption of preventive measures could help us understand how to increase immunization uptake. Much of the focus so far has rightly been on vaccine supply chains and distribution challenges.

But research shows that motivating people to take up a vaccine is vital even in the absence of misinformation and mistrust. Research conducted on immunization prior to the pandemic can inform our initial thinking on COVID-19 vaccination programs, and help us formulate strategies to help increase uptake.

Incorporating into public policy the lessons of economic research on the significance of how information is conveyed, and by whom, is particularly important in a context of information overload, misinformation, and mistrust of health systems. To help us move toward a post-pandemic world, policymakers should consider carefully how these findings could be used to increase uptake of COVID-19 vaccines.


上海久汇纺织科技有限公司

公司总机:021-58991190

销售业务部:

15601673666 胡女士

纺织新材料供应部:

18049721407 梁工

http://www.starpont.com 

EMAIL:

starpont@126.com

  • 这!就是今日纺织 | 聚焦纺织服装业,《经济日报》报道:筑牢纺织工业强国根基
    中国纺织工业联合会会长孙瑞哲表示,“十四五”时期,是在世界百年未有之大变局下,中国推进全面建设社会主义现代化国家的战略机遇期,也是行业在基本实现纺织强国目标的基础上,围绕“科技、时尚、绿色”实现更高质量、更有效率、更加公平、更可持续、更为安全发展的重要窗口期。
  • 纺织非遗助力乡村振兴 巩固脱贫成果(央广网)
    手工刺绣蓝牙音箱、扎染单肩包、缠花技艺小饰品……在我国已公布的1300多项国家级非物质文化遗产代表性项目中,纺织类非遗项目多达百余项。近年来,纺织非遗融入现代生活与消费渐成风尚。
  • 申久集团开展安全宣讲及安全风险辨识培训活动
    为贯彻“安全第一、预防为主、综合治理”的安全生产工作方针,进一步增强企业员工的安全意识,根据《江苏省工业企业风险报告规定》(省政府令第140号)等相关文件要求以及璜泾镇安全工作部署要求,申久集团组织安全管理人员开展了一次安全宣讲及安全风险辨识培训活动。
  • 省财贸轻纺工会领导莅临申久考察调研
    6月11日上午,省财贸轻纺工会二级调研员陈树礼等一行7人,在太仓市总工会副主席徐昭君、璜泾镇副镇长姚巍峰等领导的陪同下,莅临申久公司进行调研工作,申久集团副总裁邱国全、工会主席刘亚东进行了热情接待。
  • 2021潮流服装消费趋势报告(CBNData)
    CBNData联合淘宝直播ON MAP发布《2021潮流服装报告》,基于CBNData消费大数据,洞察在国潮、奥运主题大热的情况下,2021年潮流服装如何寻求增长。
  • 2021防晒趋势白皮书(CBNData)
    第一财经商业数据中心(CBNData)发布《2021防晒趋势白皮书》,分析防晒行业从市场格局到消费者需求的新变化,并总结出“全面防护、防养合一、效率至上、体验升级”四大防晒消费新趋势。
  • 2.4亿人想穿,一年订单猛涨133%,被嫌弃的黑丝又翻红了(CBNData)
    当女明星和爱豆们腿上长满了黑丝,这个前些年被嫌弃得不行的单品,如今又成了潮流风向标。
  • 淘宝直播2021年度报告(CBNData)
    2020年,直播进入了快速普及阶段,各个新品牌也纷纷开始带货。直播电商下半场,用户价值在何处?淘榜单、淘宝直播联合淘宝直播ON MAP推出的《淘宝直播2021年度报告​》,对淘宝直播的用户商业价值和货品品类进行了分析,以便品牌和商家了解行业新趋势。
  • 2021精致妈妈生活及消费趋势洞察(CBNData)
    CBNData联合复星发布《精致妈妈的生活“三重奏”——2021精致妈妈生活及消费趋势洞察》,报告以一群来自高线城市,兼顾高学历、高收入的精致妈妈为代表,通过调研精致妈妈们在不同场景下的需求,结合阿里巴巴消费大数据、公开数据及多场景数据,揭示了新时代精致妈妈如何在承担妈妈责任的同时正视自我,在舍得之间实现人生追求,并总结出了精致妈妈们消费的三大趋势。